.

Return to Home Page

Return to Home Page

previous next

March 27

| Lecture | Assignment | Links | Q&A |


News: a new comet There's a comet in the sky right now! This is Comet Ikeya-Zhang, and it has a period of 367 years. It was at its brightest on Monday, actually, and can be seen low in the Western sky with binoculars. Perhaps after the exam tonight or in lab on Thursday we can have a look!

What it looks like -- Where to find it -- Its orbit around the Sun


Sunspots--why they're dark, how they relate to magnetism What are sunspots? They're regions of the Sun that appear dark compared with the surrounding regions. They were first seen by Galileo. The temperature of the main surface of the Sun is 5,800 K, but the temperature at a Sunspot might be only 4,000 K.

Sunspots are caused by the magnetic field of the Sun getting tangled up in kinks. This happens partly as a result of the Sun's differential rotation. A magnetic field line makes charged particles follow along its path (go in circles around its path, actually.) If a magnetic field line that gets tangled up is pushed through the surface, it can slow down convection in that area.

Remember, energy from the fusion in the Sun's core (within 10% of the Sun's center) is carried to the outside first by radiation, and then in the outer 30% of the Sun, by convection, which is the boiling motion that results from sharp differences in temperature. (A hot air balloon wouldn't rise if the hot air was the same temperature as the air around it.)

The reason that there is convection in the outer 30% is that the photons are no longer that effective at smoothing out the temperatures--the big difference in temperature then causes convection to take over. In the outer 30%, the lower temepratures allow the ions to form atoms again, and the bound electrons can absorb the photons from inside the Sun much better than free elections.

So the twisted magnetic field near a sunspot makes the convecting gas inside the Sun follow along the field lines, instead of chaotically churning around. So the convection is not as effective in bringing heat out near the sunspot. Instead of hot gas rising and cool gas falling to make the surface hot and bright, gas goes where the magnetic field points, whether it is hot or cold. That's why sunspots are cooler and darker than the surrounding areas.

How do we know this? Well, we can measure magnetic fields on the surface of the Sun using something called the Zeeman effect. What appears as a single energy level in an atom is actually several different energy levels--when there's no magnetic field, those different energy levels coincide. The bigger the magnetic field, the more that single level is "split". If we look at an absorption line from the Sun and it's split into several wavelengths, how much it's split gives us a measure of the strength of the magnetic field.

Below is a magnetogram, an image of the magnetic field on the surface of the Sun, made using the Zeeman effect, from July 9, 1995:

Notice that the dark and bright spots (N and S poles) are right next to each other.


The Sunspot Cycle The sunspots follow a general progression over an 11 year cycle.

Full size image at http://science.msfc.nasa.gov/ssl/pad/solar/images/bfly.gif

The image above is called a "Butterfly Diagram" based on how it looks or a "Maunder Diagram" based on its discoverer.

What it shows is that at the start of each 11 year cycle, sunspots are formed mostly at latitudes on the Sun of around + or - 30 degrees. Then as time goes by, those sunspots fade and new sunspots are formed closer to the equator. This gives the butterfly shape. Also, more sunspots are formed as the average location for sunspots moves towards the equator of the Sun. Then you start to get fewer sunspots as they get right near the equator--finally the cycle starts over.

The Sun is more "active" when there are more sunspots, and even though sunspots are cooler than the rest of the Sun, the Sun may be brighter at "solar max" when the most sunspots are visible. By more "active", we mean that there are more eruptions on the surface of the Sun, such as solar flares. Solar flares can result from the tangled up magnetic field finding a way of untangling fast that gives off a lot of energy--like twisted up rubber bands snapping back to place. The solar flares can be extremely energetic and send particles through space on their way to Earth.

Also, the corona of the Sun (hot gas surrounding it) can be affected by the sunspot cycle and solar activity. The corona is probably kept hot by both sound waves from the Sun and by waves along the magnetic field lines (like waves on a string). Sometimes there are coronal mass ejections that send gas out into space. If the magnetic field lines of the Sun are open then gas flowing along the lines can escape the Sun into a high speed solar wind.


The causes of the Sunspot Cycle What causes the sunspot cycle? Our best understanding is that it is the result of the differential rotation of the Sun mucking up the magnetic field at its surface. Here is an illustration of what happens to the Sun's magnetic field as a result of the Sun's differential rotation:

This can explain much of what we know about the Sunspot cycle. The sunspots start out at higher latitude and then form closer to the equator, because the magnetic field gets twisted up more near the equator the longer you wait for the rotation.

Sunspots often come in pairs like a magnet--one for the north pole and the other for the south pole. The one that's "leading", has the same polarity as the pole of the Sun in that hemisphere. (Example: in the North hemisphere of the Sun, you'd see from left to right the South and then North pole of a sunspot-pair.)

Then when sunspots meet near the equator, the north and south cancel out--you start to get fewer sunspots near the end of the cycle. If you have SN in that order, and the N spot cancels out a S spot from the south pole, you end up with a S spot in the northern hemisphere and a N spot in the southern hemisphere. It's thought that these can act to cancel out the North and South poles themselves, so that every 11 years, the North and South poles of the Sun reverse! This last happened about a year ago.


The Sunspot Cycle's effect on the Earth The sunspot cycle can have important effects on the Earth!

For one, look what happened from about 1645 through 1715: observers found very few sunspots compared with before or after. It turns out that this was a time of colder temperatures, especially in Europe, and in fact this time is often called the "Little Ice Age." The Sun may have been 0.25 percent dimmer during this period!

Also, solar flares can disrupt power grids and satellite communications. They can be dangerous for astronauts above the Earth's atmosphere. But they can also create beautiful auroras near the poles!

Links

The sunspot cycle from the NASA Marshall Space Flight Center

The solar dynamo, from the NASA Marshall Space Flight Center

www.spaceweather.com tells you the latest of what's happening on the surface of the Sun and how it could affect the Earth--and much more!

Stanford Solar Center, a nice site

Page on sunspot cycles at U of Oregon

Lecture notes on the Sun by my thesis advisor

The SF Exploratorium museum has a nice page on sunspots

Images of the Sun, right now! from the SOHO Solar and Heliospheric Observatory

Solar fact sheet

They Might Be Giants sings a song called "Why Does the Sun Shine? (The Sun Is A Mass of Incandescent Gas)", based on a 1959 educational song

Solar Art

I had a very good question today--it made me go and send e-mail to a friend I knew in grad school. Just for fun, here's a picture of her getting out her frustrations with studying the Sun after completing her thesis.

Here's the correspondence.

Date: Thu, 4 Apr 2002 11:11:15 -0800
From: Bram Boroson 
To: sgibson@hao.ucar.edu, s.gibson@solar.stanford.edu
Subject: Sun's magnetic field
 
 
Hi Sarah,
 
I'm teaching an intro astronomy class and I got the following question
from a student:
 
Jupiter, like the Sun, has differential rotation.  It has a strong
magnetic field.  Why doesn't it get tangled up, producing spots of
decreased convection, field reversal, etc.?
 
One possible answer I thought of was that there might be something similar
that DOES happen on Jupiter.
 
Or it could be that the magnetic field is not frozen in to the surface of
Jupiter, as it is on the Sun, because Jupiter's atmosphere isn't ionized
enough.
 
So I'm asking you, the expert--what's a better answer?
 
Thanks, I hope all's going well!
 
Bram
And here was the reply from her husband, who I also went to grad school with:

Date: Fri, 5 Apr 2002 13:32:21 -0700 (MST)
From: Mark Miesch 
To: bboroson@jsd.claremont.edu
Cc: sgibson@ucar.edu, miesch@ucar.edu
Subject: Re: Sun's magnetic field
 
 
Hi Bram -
 
Good to hear from you!
 
Your question is more my territory than Sarah's so she unloaded it
on me.  You're right - the reason we don't see the magnetic field
playing a big role in the atmospheric dynamics of Jupiter and the
other Jovian planets is because their atmospheres aren't
sufficiently ionized.  The field must play a big dynamical role
in the metallic hydrogen core where it's presumably generated
by convection and differential rotation but the visible cloud layer
is only the outer skin of the planet so we don't see any of that.

 
Does Jupiter have magnetic cycles like the Sun?  Apparently not.
It's global field hasn't reversed since we've been measuring it.
However, the first direct measurement wasn't made until we started
sending spacecraft there in the '70s so we have no clue if the field
is cyclic or not on long time scales.  There is alot of time variation
in the magnetosphere but that's mostly due to interaction with ionized
particles from Io, not the jovian dynamo itself.  Not much is understood
about how Jupiter's dynamo works but it's probably a bit different
from the Sun, mostly  because it has a different geometry (convective
core vs convective envelope).
 
I hope this answers your question.  Happy to help out!
 
Take care and Best Wishes!
- Mark

previous next

Return to Home Page